Traditional gas central heating vs. air-to-air heat pumps - which is best?

Expert guide to gas central heating & air source heat pumps

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare traditional gas central heating systems with modern air-to-air heat pumps, highlighting the many benefits of air-to-air heat pumps and explain why they may be the perfect choice for your home. Let’s explore the details.

We’re your local specialists in air-to-air heat pump installations across the UK Midlands, with over 25 years of expertise through the WBH Industries Group. Air-to-air heat pump systems offer a fantastic opportunity to save money while enhancing your home’s heating and cooling comfort. Plus, their impressive environmental credentials help reduce reliance on fossil fuels.

What are air to air heat pumps?

An air-to-air heat pump is a highly efficient system designed to manage both heating and cooling for your home. This technology leverages the principles of thermodynamics to transfer heat between the outside air and your indoor space.

How it works

Air-to-air heat pumps operate using a refrigeration cycle that consists of four main stages: evaporation, compression, condensation, and expansion. Here’s a breakdown of each stage:

Evaporation: The system starts by absorbing heat from the outside air through the evaporator coils. Even in colder weather, there is some heat available in the air.
Compression: The absorbed heat is then compressed by the compressor. This compression process increases the temperature of the heat, making it more effective for heating your home.
Condensation: The hot, high-pressure refrigerant is transferred to the condenser coils inside your home. As the refrigerant cools, it releases its heat, warming the indoor air.
Expansion: The refrigerant then goes through an expansion valve, reducing its pressure and temperature before it is cycled back outside to start the process again.

Types of air-to-air heat pumps

Single-Split Systems: These consist of one indoor unit and one outdoor unit. They are suitable for heating or cooling individual rooms.
Multi-Split Systems: These have one outdoor unit connected to multiple indoor units, allowing for zoned climate control across different rooms.

Advantages

Efficiency: Air-to-air heat pumps are highly efficient, often providing up to four times the energy they consume.
Versatility: They offer both heating and cooling functions.
Air Quality: They help improve indoor air quality by filtering and dehumidifying the air.

What is a traditional central heating system?

Traditional gas central heating systems have been the standard method for home heating for many years. These systems use a gas-fired boiler to heat water, which is then circulated through radiators or underfloor heating systems to warm your home.

How it works

Boiler: The system begins with a gas boiler that burns natural gas to generate heat.
Pipes: The heated water travels through a network of pipes to radiators or underfloor heating systems throughout the house.
Radiators/Underfloor Heating: Radiators or underfloor heating units release the heat into the rooms, providing warmth.
Thermostat: A thermostat controls the temperature by regulating the flow of hot water.

Components

Gas Boiler: The central unit responsible for heating the water.
Radiators/Underfloor Heating: Devices that distribute heat throughout the home.
Pipes: They carry the hot water to and from the boiler.

Advantages

Familiar Technology: It’s a well-understood system that has been used for decades.
Effective Heating: Provides consistent and reliable warmth.

The benefits of air to air heat pumps

EXCEPTIONAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY - Air-to-air heat pumps are renowned for their energy efficiency. They work by transferring heat rather than generating it, which means they can provide up to four units of heat for every unit of electricity consumed. This remarkable efficiency reduces your energy consumption and lowers your utility bills.
YEAR-ROUND COMFORT - These systems offer both heating and cooling capabilities, making them versatile for all seasons. In winter, they provide warmth by extracting heat from the outside air. In summer, they switch to cooling mode, removing heat from inside your home. This dual functionality eliminates the need for separate air conditioning units.
IMPROVED INDOOR AIR QUALITY - Air-to-air heat pumps enhance indoor air quality by filtering and dehumidifying the air. This helps remove allergens, dust, and pollutants, making your home a healthier environment, especially beneficial for those with respiratory conditions or allergies.
MINIMAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT - Air-to-air heat pumps are environmentally friendly since they rely on electricity, which can be sourced from renewable energy. Unlike gas boilers, they produce no direct emissions, contributing to a reduction in your carbon footprint.
COST SAVINGS - Due to their high efficiency, air-to-air heat pumps can lead to significant savings on your energy bills. Additionally, the cost of installing these systems is often lower than other advanced heating technologies, providing a cost-effective solution for homeowners.
HASSLE-FREE INSTALLATION - The installation process for air-to-air heat pumps is generally straightforward. They don’t require extensive pipework or modifications to existing systems, unlike traditional heating systems. This means less disruption to your home and a quicker installation process.
LOW MAINTENANCE - Air-to-air heat pumps are low maintenance compared to traditional gas systems. They typically require only periodic checks and basic upkeep, whereas gas boilers often need more frequent servicing and maintenance.

The disadvantages of gas central heating

CARBON EMISSIONS - Gas central heating systems emit carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases as they burn natural gas. This contributes to global warming and climate change, making them less environmentally friendly compared to newer technologies.
FUEL DEPENDENCY - These systems rely on a steady supply of natural gas, which can be subject to market fluctuations and supply disruptions. This dependency can lead to higher costs or availability issues.
HIGH INSTALLATION COSTS - The initial installation of a gas central heating system can be expensive. Costs include the boiler, radiators, pipes, and potentially significant infrastructure changes, especially for homes without existing gas lines.
REGULAR MAINTENANCE - Gas central heating systems require regular maintenance to ensure safety and efficiency. This includes checking for leaks, servicing the boiler, and maintaining the radiators. The ongoing cost of maintenance can add up over time.
SAFETY RISKS - There is a risk of gas leaks, which can lead to dangerous situations like carbon monoxide poisoning or explosions if not properly managed. Regular maintenance is crucial to mitigate these risks.
ENERGY INEFFICIENCY - Older gas heating systems may be less energy-efficient compared to newer technologies. This inefficiency can result in higher energy bills and greater environmental impact.
SPACE REQUIREMENTS - Gas boilers and radiators can take up significant space in your home. This can be a disadvantage for those with limited space or for homeowners who prefer a more streamlined heating system.
FOSSIL FUEL USE - Natural gas is a fossil fuel, and its extraction and use can have adverse environmental impacts, including habitat disruption and pollution.
HIGHER OPERATING COSTS: Gas central heating can lead to significantly higher energy bills, especially during the colder winter months.

Comparing running costs: air-to-air heat pump systems vs. gas central heating

When it comes to running costs, air-to-air heat pumps have a clear edge over traditional gas central heating systems. The efficiency of air-to-air heat pumps means they consume less energy to provide the same level of heating or cooling.

Cost comparison – For example, an average UK home using a gas boiler might consume around 1000 kWh of energy per month for heating. An air-to-air heat pump could provide the same amount of heating with only about 333 kWh of energy. This represents an approximate 400% efficiency improvement, leading to lower monthly energy bills.

Energy savings – The energy savings translate directly into cost savings. With reduced energy consumption, your utility bills will decrease, making air-to-air heat pumps a cost-effective choice in the long term. Over time, the savings on your energy bills can offset the initial investment in the heat pump system.

Comparing installation costs: air-to-air heat pump systems vs. gas central heating

In terms of installation costs, air-to-air heat pumps are generally more affordable than some advanced heating technologies like air-to-water or ground-source heat pumps. Here’s a comparison of the costs:

Air-to-air heat pumps – Installation costs for air-to-air heat pumps are typically lower than those for air-to-water or ground-source heat pumps. Additionally, the VAT-free installation offer further reduces the overall cost. Air-to-air heat pumps don’t require extensive modifications or removal of existing systems, which helps keep the installation process straightforward and cost-effective.

Gas central heating – The installation of a gas central heating system can be more expensive due to the cost of the boiler, radiators, pipes, and potentially significant infrastructure changes. For homes without existing gas lines, the costs can be even higher, as new gas lines and fittings may be required.

Overall cost effectiveness

When considering both installation and running costs, air-to-air heat pumps often provide a more cost-effective solution compared to traditional gas central heating systems. Their lower installation costs, combined with significant energy savings, make them an attractive option for many homeowners.

Air to air heat pumps air conditioning – the cool advantage

One of the standout features of air-to-air heat pumps is their air conditioning capability. Unlike traditional heating systems that require separate air conditioning units, air-to-air heat pumps provide both heating and cooling from a single system.

Cooling efficiency

In the summer months, air-to-air heat pumps operate in cooling mode. They work by removing heat from the indoor air and transferring it outside, effectively cooling your home. This eliminates the need for separate air conditioning units, providing a streamlined solution for year-round comfort.

Benefits of integrated air conditioning

Convenience: having both heating and cooling in one system simplifies your climate control needs.
Space saving: eliminates the need for additional air conditioning units, freeing up space in your home.
Cost efficiency: combines two functions in one system, potentially reducing overall equipment and installation costs.

Reviews of air to air source heat pumps

Definitely recommend these guys. Gary's service and help is second to none. A real credit to the business. Thanks again

Best company excellent service. Gary and Paul both very helpfull.I would definitely recommend this company to everyone.

The service was excellent from start to finish. Survey and installation were second to none. Price is reasonable. The communication was excellent as well where our request of availability for installation was taken into account. Highly recommended.

Without doubt the best company i have dealt with. From initial enquiry, excellent communication all the way through. The fitter left absolutely no trace that he'd been in the house. Would definitely use again

Smooth, quick process from start to finish. Quick delivery and fitting was super simple. thanks again

Gary has been really efficient, clear and helpful at every stage of ordering. Highly recommend

Fabulous product, great customer service, would definitely recommend

Excellent communication , service and product ! Very pleased .

Good company. Great product

FAQs for our air source heat pumps

What is the lifespan of an air-to-air heat pump?

Air-to-air heat pumps typically have a lifespan of 15 to 20 years, depending on maintenance and usage. Regular servicing can help extend the life of your system.

How much maintenance do air-to-air heat pumps require?

Air-to-air heat pumps require minimal maintenance. Regular checks and basic upkeep, such as cleaning the filters and ensuring the system is free of debris, are usually sufficient.

Can an air-to-air heat pump replace my existing heating system?

Yes, an air-to-air heat pump can replace a traditional gas central heating system. It provides both heating and cooling, offering a versatile and efficient solution for your home.

Are air-to-air heat pumps noisy?

Modern air-to-air heat pumps are designed to operate quietly. The noise level is generally comparable to that of a refrigerator, and most homeowners find it unobtrusive.

Can air-to-air heat pumps be used in all climates?

Air-to-air heat pumps are suitable for a wide range of climates. They are particularly effective in temperate climates and can still provide efficient heating even in colder weather.

What are the environmental benefits of air-to-air heat pumps?

Air-to-air heat pumps have a minimal environmental impact as they use electricity, which can be sourced from renewable energy. They produce no direct emissions, making them a more sustainable choice compared to fossil fuel-based systems.

How do I know if an air-to-air heat pump is right for my home?

Our team at WarmVent can assess your home’s specific needs and provide a recommendation based on factors such as size, insulation, and energy efficiency goals. We offer free consultations to help you determine the best solution.

Warmvent Blog

Learn more about air-to-air heat pumps...

Air-to-air heat pumps

Your Complete Guide to Air to Air AC and Heating

Explore How Air To Air AC And Heating Can Transform Your Home With Energy-Efficient Year-Round Comfort. Learn More From WarmVent’s Expert Team.

November 14, 2024